Material Overview
Material for Additive Extrusion
Additive Extrusion with thermoplastics
Additive Extrusion is a process in which a thermoplastic material or a semi-finished product is continuously conveyed, melted and deposited along a tool path to form a structure. To enhance the structural performance the integration of continuous fiber reinforcements to increase stiffness and strength as well as the insertion of functionalized elements for sensory or electrical purposes are of particular interest.
During an Additive Extrusion process a material has to change from solid to liquid back to solid multiple times. Therefore only meltable polymers like thermoplastics and thermoplastic elastomers can be processed.
Overview of meltable polymers usable for Additive Extrusion processes.
Source: DLR, own illustration.
Thermoplastic Polymers
In the area of thermoplastics a variety of different polymers are available, that can be divided in semi-crystalline and amorph types. Based on their overall performance those polymers can be labeled as commodity, engineering or high performance thermoplastics.
Overview of available polymers in the area of thermoplastics.
Source: Own illustration.
The material properties of a raw polymers can be adjusted by mixing with reinforcing fillers (composites), mixing with other polymer types (blends) or mixing with further special additives. Thus the overall performance can be enhanced and materials can be customized to meet specific requirements. For this reason, hundreds of different thermoplastic polymer grades are available for almost every kind of special application.
Feedstocks for Additive Extrusion
Depending on the extrusion unit different types of feedstock can be processed. Currently, filament is the most common feedstock type for additive extrusion. However, some processes, especially for large scale additive manufacturing, also run with granules.
Filament Granules Powders
Different types of processible feedstock for an Additive Extrusion process.
Source: DLR, own illustration.
A lot of thermoplastic polymers are already available as filaments for Additive Extrusion:
- PLA, PET(-G), ABS and ASA are the most common polymers, due to their good printability (low warpage, rather low extrusion temperatures, rather good bed adhesion, no need for a heated build chamber)
- Well known polymers like PA, PP, PC that are frequently used in other plastic manufactruing processes are also available but harder to print
- Different high performance polymers can be used for professional applications but are more expensive and require advanced printing systems in most cases
Overview of thermoplastic polymers available as filaments for Additive Extrusion.
Source: DLR, own illustration.
Mechanical Properties of Filament Feedstocks
The following figure intends to give an overview on the mechanical performance of neat filament feedstock as well as glass fiber (GF) and carbon fiber (CF) filled filament feedstocks that are currently available on the market. The mechanical properties were measured on specimens that were printed flat on the print bed with 100% ± 45° infill.
Overview of the mechanical performance of neat filament feedstocks.
Source: DLR, own illustration.
Development of optimized materials for Additive Extrusion
Most of the available thermoplastic grades have been developed for conventional processing technologies like injection molding and are not optimized for Additive Extrusion technologies. Therefore over the years often only pure, unmodified polymers are used for filament production. For a lot of polymers (especially semi-crystalline types) this results in filaments with bad printability and consequently bad performance of printed components. Furthermore in this case, one of the key strengths of polymer material systems, which is the possibility to tailor the material properties according to specific requirements, can not be exploited.
Thus in order to realize the full potential of Additive Extrusion, the development of polymer grades specifically designed for Additive Extrusion processesing is necessary. Some properties that have to be considered during the development are mentioned below:
- Shrinkage
- Layer adhesion
- Processing temperature
- Viscosity
- Melting/crystallization behaviour
At the moment more and more of those optimized polymer grades, specifically developed for Additive Extrusion become available on the market with some of those grades having additional funtionalities like increased electrical conductivity or increased flame or wear resistance.
Also short fibers (chopped carbon or glass fibers) are frequently used as fillers with volume contents in some cases above 30 vol%. Short fibers present very important fillers for Additive extrusion materials for multiple reasons:
- Increase thermal conductivity --> improved layer bonding
- Reduce thermal shrinkage --> reduced warpage
- Reinforce the polymer --> improved overall mechanical performance
Additive Extrusion with continous fiber reinforcement
In most of the applications where Additive Extrusion is currently applied, neat thermoplastic materials are used. For engeneering applications with higher requirements with regard to the mechanical performance of manufactured components, those neat thermoplastics are reinforced with short fibers. However, for structural components that carry high mechanical loads for example in leightweight constructions in aerospace, automotive or wind power industry where metal components are to be replaced, the performance of neat and short fiber reinforced thermoplasts is not sufficient.
An approach to open up such applications for Additive Extrusion, is the integration of continuous fibers in Additive Extrusion processes. The possibility to combine the extraordinary mechanical properties of continuous fibers with the the design and manufacturing freedom of Additive Extrusion, allows the alignment of continuous fibers specifically along critical load paths and thus the production of efficient leightweight constructions based on continuous fiber reinforced thermoplastics.
Neat and different fiber reinforced structures.
Source: DLR, own illustration.
Continuous fiber reinforced thermoplasts
Due to continuous fiber reinforcement, the mechanical performance of composites in fiber direction improves dramatically. Often duromers are used as matrix systems for the fibers because their low viscosity in the resin states simplifies the fiber impregnation. For thermoplastic matrix systems the fiber impregnation becomes more difficult as the melt viscosities are higher. Therefore continuous fiber reinforced thermoplastic materials are usually available as semi-finished products, with fibers being pre-impregnated by the thermoplastic matrix. Most common are unidirectional reinforced tapes (UD tapes) consisting of one fiber layer. The fiber matrix adhesion in those composites is optimized by specific sizing systems.
- Fiber volume content: up to ~ 70 vol%, 0° tensile strength up to 2500 MPa
- Void content: < 1 % after consolidation, 0° tensile modulus up to 150 GPa
Description of a continiuous fiber reinforced thermoplast. Source: DLR, own illustration
Potential of continuous carbon fiber reinforcement for Additive Extrusion
To illustrate the potential that continuous fiber reinforcement could present for Additive Extrusion technologies, the following figure compares the basic mechanical properties of additively extruded components (including neat and short fiber reinforced materials) with those of some typical unidirectional carbon fiber reinfroced UD tapes in fiber direction (0°-direction). It is evident that continuous fiber reinforcement could extent the range of possible applications for Additive Extrusion technologies significantly.
Comparison of the potential of components with and without continiuous fiber reinforcement.
Source: DLR, own illustration.
Feedstocks for Additive Extrusion with continuous fiber reinforcement
Additive Extrusion with continuous fiber reinforcement combines the mechanical performance of fibers with the processing advantages of Additive Extrusion. For this reason, most of those technologies consist of at least two extrusion/deposition units: One for conventional for "conventional" Filament Depostion Modelling (FDM) without continuous fiber reinforcement and one for the deposition of continuous fiber reinforced material. This allows to place the fibers specifically along the critical load paths while the rest of the component can be printed conventionally without unnecessary continuous fiber reinforcement to safe material costs. The depostion process for the continuous fiber reinforced material can be an FDM-like process or a tape laying process. Therefore feedstocks for Additive Extrusion with continuous fiber reinforcement can be either special UD-tapes or Continuous fiber reinforced (CFR) filaments.
Extrusion/deposition units of an Additive Extrusion technology. Source: DLR, own illustration.
While a varierty of UD tapes is commercially available, CFR-filaments are not. Currently, providers of extrusion systems that can process continuous fiber reinforced materials also offer the suitable material systems for their devices. Because extrusion technologies of different providers differ too much, material systems usually are not interchangeable from system to system. This leads to a rather limited variety of available materials in general but especially when considering only one specific extrusion technology. This limited material spectrum provides one of the key challenges in the area of Additive Extrusion with continuous fiber reinforcement.
The following figure illustrates this limited material spectrum. At the moment the polymers primarily used for CFRP-filaments are high performance grades like PEEK and PEKK as well as the well known engineering thermoplastic PA.
Overview of thermoplastic polymers available as Continuous Fiber Reinforced (CFR)-Filaments for Additive Extrusion.
Source: DLR, own illustration.
Quality Aspects of Material Microstructure
Below, basic quality aspects of composite material microstructure are discussed. These aspects have significant effect on the macroscopic mechanical properties of a printer fiber-reinforced part.
Fiber Impregnation
In fiber-reinforced composites, the polymer matrix is responsible for the load transfer to the fibers. Therefore, the single continuous fibers need to be completely coated by matrix material and well bonded together, to enable a good load transfer between fibers and matrix. This step of infiltration of dry fibers, often thousands of single continuous fibers with a diameter of approximately 4-7 micrometer are present, by polymer matrix is understood as impregnation. Not or bad impregnated fibers do not participate in load transfer and therefore, do not contribute to the mechanical performance of the composite. Thus, a sufficient impregnation is essential to achieve a high mechanical strength and stiffness. Especially for high viscous matrix materials, like thermoplastics, the impregnation is a challenging task.
Fiber-Matrix-Bonding
In addition to a good impregnation, the fiber-matrix-bonding needs to be sufficient for an effective load transfer between fiber and matrix. This means proper wetting and adhesion of the polymer matrix material to the fibers has to be ensured. Conventionally a sizing is applied to the fiber surface aiming to improve the fiber-matrix-bonding.
Fiber Volume Content
The fiber volume content significantly effects the performance of the fiber-reinforced materials, especially in fiber direction. It describes the ratio of volume the composite part filled with fibers. As more fibers are present, as stronger the mechanical properties are increased. Typical ratios for continuous fiber-reinforced composite materials are in the range of 45% to 65% depending on the application and manufacturing technology.
Fiber Distribution
The fiber distribution describes how homogeneously the single continuous fibers are distributed in the matrix material. Agglomerations of fibers and larger zones of bulk matrix should be avoided, to prevent mechanical performance reductions.
Fiber Waviness
The fiber waviness describes the degree of a fiber being wrinkled, folded, buckled, undulated or misaligned from its foreseen ideal path. This kind of effect cannot be completely prevented, especially in the area of higher fiber path curvatures. Nevertheless, the fiber waviness influences the load distribution and particularly reduces compression strength. Often it is differentiated between in-plane waviness, meaning the waviness regarding the plane of material deposition, and out-of-plane waviness, meaning the perpendicular thickness direction from the plane of material deposition.
Voids
Voids can be described as small cavity volumes inside the composite material that are not filled with matrix or fiber. These irregularities disturb the load distribution and especially affect the matrix dominated composite properties like interlaminar shear strength (ILLS) or compressive strength. Furthermore, they can be a nucleus for crack initiation under cyclic loading. The occurrence of voids cannot be completely suppressed, but the maximum allowable void volume content is often restricted based on the application and industrial sector.
Layer Bonding
Layer bonding describes the adhesion properties at the interface of a strand deposited to a previously laid one. Thus, this somehow describes the transition from microstructural properties to macrostructural properties. Only if sufficient adhesion can be ensured, an even load distribution between the deposited strands is possible. The layer bonding is strongly affected by viscous flow and diffusion of polymeric chains.AM-CFRP processes typically create the part volume by successively adding several continuous fiber-reinforced material strands together. This means the final part geometry possibly consists of thousands deposited strands. The composite microstructure of the part highly influences the overall mechanical performance. Especially if pre-impregnated fiber products are processed, their initial material quality will have a high effect on the final part quality.
Technology Overview
State of the Art Additive Extrusion
Additive Manufacturing with Continuous Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Materials
(AM-CFRP)
Additive Manufacturing in general describes a process in which a part volume is created by successively adding material in a defined construction space. Today a lot of different processes with different technological maturity levels are available for a wide variety of materials like polymer, metal, ceramic or composites. The DLR Innovation Lab EmpowerAX focuses on Additive Manufacturing with fiber-reinforced polymer materials and primarily those with continuous fiber-reinforcement. For this type of material class again a lot of different additive process technology approaches are in development. Following a general overview of the state of the art in Additive Manufacturing with Continuous Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Materials (AM-CFRP) will be given. Benefits and possible obstacles for the application of these processes are discussed, existing technology providers and their processes are shown and important basic understanding of process specialties are given.
The final result of an Additive Manufacturing process with continuous fiber-reinforced materials is a polymer structure, which volume is up to a percentage of 65% filled with most likely equally distributed continuous fibers, e.g. carbon or glass. The reinforcing with continuous fibers may increase the tensile modulus by a factor of 100 and the tensile strength by a factor of 1000 compared to a pure polymer part (see State of the Art Materials). As these improved strength and stiffness is only effective in fiber direction, the orientation of the fibers should be as good as possible aligned in coincidence with the load paths of the structure. Continuous fiber-reinforced materials are a subclass of composites, which also covers short and long fiber-reinforcements. Typical applications scenarios for AM-CFRP can be divided in those aiming to add a continuous fiber-reinforced structure onto an existing part, e.g. stiffening of a shell structure, and the ones an independent part should be produced.
Stiffening of surfaces with continuous fiber-reinforced struts manufactured by Additive Extrusion. Source: DLR, own illustration.
All available technological approaches for AM-CFRP therefore have in common, that they somehow are able to align continuous fibers in a build volume, whereas each single fiber is enclosed by a polymeric matrix. The matrix keeps the fibers in place to ensure the geometrical dimensions and transfer the loads to the fibers. The fibers are carrying the loads and drastically increase the strength and stiffness of the part. In difference to more conventional manufacturing technologies for composite parts, AM processes promise a higher design freedom and less tooling costs utilizing highly automated equipment. An ideal AM process would be invariant against different geometries or fiber path planning and not challenge the operator with highly specific expertise. However, there is no commonly agreed strict differentiation, when a composite process is considered to be “Additive Manufacturing" or “3D-printing". As a generic process for AM-CFRP capable to deal with all kinds of materials, geometries or underlying economic conditions is not present today, each industrial available approach has its own strength and weakness. These need to be well understood to really take advantage of Additive Manufacturing with continuous fiber-reinforced materials.
Process chain of an Additive Extrusion Process.Source: DLR, own Illustration.
The first step of a typical process chain is the geometrical design (CAD) of the part to be manufactured, which also includes the fiber path planning. Afterwards this is translated into machine tool path trajectories and related machine code (CAM); simplified the build planning. Once the machine code file is finished, the Additive Manufacturing of the part can be executed. For that purpose, semi-finished fiber products like dry fiber rovings, pre-impregnated filaments or tapes are processed by an additive manufacturing end-effector / tool, the “print head". The machine code file typically contains the movement of the tool center point in the build volume as well as the tool-path related control commands for the print head. This file is interpreted by a controller, often a CNC-controller, e.g. from Bosch, Beckhoff or Siemens. For the necessary movements, the print head is assembled to a kinematic system like a 3-axis or 5-axis machine, a gantry system or a CNC-controlled robot. Some AM-CFRP processes have a multi-step approach. This means that once a preliminary continuous fiber-reinforced part or component is additively manufactured, additional process steps are necessary to get to the final part. There are different perspectives to distinguish between available AM-CFRP processes:
Polymeric matrix material
In general, there are two different classes of polymeric matrix materials used for composites. Thermoplastic materials like PA, PPS, PEI, PEKK and thermoset materials like UV-curing resins. Thermoset resins are low viscous and therefore fiber impregnation is much easier. Thermoplastics needs much higher effort for impregnation but can be molten again, as the polymeric chains do not crosslink.
Semi-finished fiber product (feedstock)
There are two main approaches. Processes working with not specially pre-treated dry fibers and those using pre-infiltrated/pre-impregnated fiber products like hybrid yarns, filaments or tapes. Especially if thermoplastic matrix materials are used, pre-impregnated products allow to reduce the process complexity as the challenging fiber-impregnation is outsourced in a preliminary and independent process step. However, the operator is tied to those materials available from certain suppliers and the initial material costs are a lot higher. By utilizing dry fibers, material costs are drastically reduced as impregnation takes place in-situ during the process. Especially for thermoplastic matrix extremely efforts need to be undertaken to ensure good impregnation quality. Therefore, systems processing pre-impregnated semi-finished products are nowadays more spread than those with in-situ impregnation, if thermoplastic matrix is required.
Consolidation
The consolidation in composites production describes the creation of the final part geometry and microstructure. Often this includes pressure and heat to compact the deposited material. Thus, voids are reduced and fiber impregnation as well as fiber distribution may be improved. Consolidation in AM-CFRP can take place as inherent property during material deposition, in-situ by directly consolidating the material in a coupled process (e.g. consolidation roller) or in an independent subsequent process step like hot pressing.
External tooling
All AM-CFRP processes need a starting point for adding new material. Most processes work with a substrate the material is deposited on like a build plate or a previously created part structure. Some processes utilize external tooling, e.g. a metal tool, which has to be specifically created for a certain geometry and fiber path planning.All available technologies for AM-CFRP combine the aforementioned points in different ways. Following it is attempted to cluster similar process schemes:
1. Direct Impregnation
Most likely dry fiber rovings are impregnated inline during the process before being deposited in build volume. The impregnation step can occur directly prior to the conveying through the print head or inside it. If the material is not getting solid again between impregnation step and material deposition in build volume, which would be a combination of in-line impregnation and direct extrusion, the continuous fiber-reinforced material needs to be pulled through the print head due to its lack of compressive rigidity.
Major advantage is that dry fiber rovings are in comparison a lot cheaper than pre-impregnated materials as feedstock and the process offers a higher material flexibility for the operator. But the incorporated impregnation process can increase the process complexity. High attention should be paid to a sufficient material consolidation.
2. Direct Extrusion
Pre-impregnated continuous fiber-reinforced fiber products, most common filaments, are conveyed through a heated nozzle to soften or even completely melt the material prior to depositing it in the build volume. As the pre-impregnated fiber products as feedstock material are solid, the conveying through the print head and deposition of material can occur due to pushing, pulling or a mixture of both.
A main benefit is the direct processing of pre-impregnated materials, which can reduce the process complexity. Also, no additional process element for polymer processing is needed. High attention should be paid to a sufficient material consolidation.
3. Co-Extrusion
Pre-impregnated continuous fiber-reinforced fiber products, most common filaments, are conveyed through a heated nozzle to soften or even completely melt the material and form a first material stream. This first stream is further mixed with a second polymer melt stream and the combined material streams are deposited in the build volume.
A main benefit is the direct processing of pre-impregnated materials, which can reduce the process complexity. Due to the addition of polymer melt to the pre-impregnated fiber product, the initial fiber volume content is reduced. High attention should be paid to a sufficient material consolidation.
4. Fiber Placement + in-situ Consolidation
These processes are really close or even identical to Automated Fiber Placement (AFP). Thermoplastic pre-impregnated continuous fiber-reinforced products like tapes with small width (slit tapes) or filaments are conveyed to the place in build volume, where they shall be deposited to a substrate. The fiber product is heated in the immediate vicinity of its placement point (nip point) to allow sufficient bonding to the substrate. Further, the deposited material is directly consolidated in a coupled process step using a compression force. Thus, material placement and in-situ consolidation constantly take place during the successive adding of material volume in build space to create a final part structure.
Due to the integrated in-situ consolidation and based on the development of Automated Fiber Placement processes in the recent years, a quite high and stable material quality may possibly be guaranteed. Based on the working principle, a suitable substrate for material deposition and carrying of consolidation forces is always required.
5. Preforming + Tool Consolidation
Most common, thermoplastic pre-impregnated continuous fiber-reinforced products like tapes or filaments are processed to preforms. These preforms can constitute simple geometrical elements like curved rods or even highly complex parts like a bracket. In a separated process step the preforms are deposited in an external tool - most likely from metal -, which represents the negative shape of the desired final part geometry. This step also allows the assembling of preforms and further adding of inserts. The final part geometry and microstructure is obtained by consolidating the preforms in the external tool, e.g. in a hot pressing or a compression molding process.
Especially if identical geometrical elements or parts have to be produced, this process approach can be beneficial. Due to consolidation in an external tool a high and stable material quality may possibly be guaranteed, but the tool needs to be designed specifically for the certain part geometry.
Benefits of AM-CFRP
The main potential benefits of Additive Manufacturing with continuous fiber-reinforced polymers are discussed below. General motivations why composite materials might be advantageous for industrial application, like the high strength and stiffness while being extremely lightweight, are not explicitly outpointed.
-
Reduced tooling costs for composite manufacturing
In conventional composite manufacturing, typically an external tool as negative form is needed to place the continuous fibers. The design and manufacturing of such tools often require high expertise, are time demanding and expensive. AM-CFRP processes ease or completely avoid necessary tooling. Some processes work with a universal build platform the material is attached to, some are first printing a tool the material is then deposited on and others at least ease the procedure of material lay-up in an external tooling.
-
Increased design freedom regarding fiber alignment
The used semi-finished fiber products in AM-CFRP have a quite low width in cross-sectional area and therefore allow highly increased geometrical resolution in the final part. In difference to wide tapes, the quite narrow deposited strands allow a lot of higher curvatures in fiber path, as the deviation of fiber path length between inner and outer boundary for small radiuses is much lower. Also, the material is added “strand-wise”, which enables a better tailoring of fiber path orientation to design needs. Especially, if compared to the use of fiber fabrics. Of course, at least the manufacturing equipment constitute a restriction, as the deposition path needs to be accessible for the print head.
-
Economic use of composites for individual parts
AM-CFRP processes show fewer manufacturing restrictions for the part design. Due to this better decoupling of design and manufacturability, the risk of detrimental effects of part design on manufacturing efficiency is reduced. The design engineers can better focus on the part requirements and considerations of “design for manufacturing” can be downstreamed. Especially for highly individual parts this reduces the efforts, typically needed in composite manufacturing for part and process design. Therefore, also single part manufacturing and small series can be economical realized from composite materials.
-
Reduced required expertise in working with composites
The handling of the anisotropic composite material is demanding in design and manufacturing, if not having been in touch with that material class before. AM-CFRP comes with highly automated process chains. Especially in manufacturing a lot of the required know-how is already included and needed operator interactions are substantially reduced. This allows production of composite parts without highly in-depth knowledge and distinct practical experience.
-
Increased resource efficiency in part manufacturing
By being an additive and not a subtractive process technology, material is only placed where it is needed. Compared to other composite manufacturing techniques, cutting waste is reduced and, due to the ability to better match material placement to structural needs, the material properties can be better exploited.Of course, for every application scenario it needs to be individually proofed, whether AM-CFRP can really create an added value. The use of pre-impregnated fiber products means increased costs for raw material and the high freedom for material placement show reduced production output ratio compared to high throughput technologies. EmpowerAX assists the assessment of technological suitability by the development of multi-stage evaluation chains and technology assessment program.
Technology Providers
A lot of different providers for AM-CFRP are on the market. Some of the available technologies belong to companies well established in composites sector, but many are related to new players in this field. Following schematic gives a short overview of available technological approaches and potential suppliers:
9T-Labs - https://www.9tlabs.com/
9T-Labs describes its technological approach as “Additive Fusion Technology” (AFT). This is a two-step process and can be related to the Preforming + Tool Consolidation scheme. The first step is a Direct Extrusion approach, in which a slit tape is reshaped inside a print head by roll forming to a strand geometry. This strand is then deposited in a build volume to print a part preform. Even complex shapes can be printed. The preform is in a second step placed in an external metal tool to consolidate the material in a hot press.
Anisoprint - https://anisoprint.com/
Anisoprint uses a Co-Extrusion approach. A pre-impregnated continuous fiber-reinforced thermoset filament is fused together with the melt flow of a neat polymer filament inside a print head. The technology is named Composite Fiber Co-extrusion (CFC).
APS Tech Solutions - https://aps-techsolutions.com/en
The technology of APS Tech Solutions can be described as a Direct Extrusion approach. A pre-impregnated continuous fiber-reinforced filament is deposited through a print head in a build volume.
AREVO - https://arevo.com/
The AQUA System from AREVO can be related to the process scheme of Material Placement + In-situ Consolidation. A pre-impregnated continuous fiber-reinforced filament is deposited in build volume and directly consolidated by a roller.
ARRIS Composites - https://arriscomposites.com/
ARRIS names its technology Additive Molding™, which can be related to the process scheme of Preforming + Tool Consolidation. Pre-impregnated continuous fiber-reinforced products are automatically shaped to preforms, which are assembled in an external tool. In the following compression molding step the material is consolidated to obtain the final part.
CEAD - https://ceadgroup.com/
CEAD uses a Co-Extrusion approach utilizing a pellet extruder for providing a main melt flow and introducing pre-impregnated continuous fiber-reinforced filaments inside the nozzle.
Continuous Composites - https://www.continuouscomposites.com/
The process of Continuous Composites is named CF3D and uses dry fiber roving which is in-situ impregnated with a thermoset resin. This infiltrated continuous fiber-reinforced material is then deposited in build volume and directly cured.
Desktop Metal - https://www.desktopmetal.com/products/fiber
The system Fiber™ from Desktop Metal can be described as micro AFP process and therefore related to the process scheme of Material Placement + In-situ Consolidation. A pre-impregnated continuous fiber-reinforced slit tape is deposited in build volume and directly consolidated by a roller.
Electroimpact - https://www.electroimpact.com/3d/overview.aspx
The Scalable Composite Robotic Additive Manufacturing system (SCRAM) from Electroimpact can be described as Material Placement + In-situ Consolidation approach. Pre-impregnated continuous fiber-reinforced slit tape is deposited in build volume and directly consolidated.
Ingersoll Machine Tools - Link follows
Ingersoll Machine Tools names its technology MasterPrint CF, which can be described as direct extrusion approach. A pre-impregnated continuous fiber-reinforced filament is deposited through a print head in a build volume.
MANTIS Composites - http://www.mantiscomposites.com/
The technology of MANTIS composites can be related to the Direct Extrusion process scheme. A pre-impregnated continuous fiber-reinforced filament is deposited through a print head in a build volume.
Markforged - https://markforged.com/
Markforged offers printers working according to the process scheme of Direct Extrusion. Pre-impregnated continuous fiber-reinforced filaments are deposited through a print head in a build volume.
Moi Composites - https://www.moi.am/
Moi composites names its technology Continuous Fiber Manufacturing (CFM), which can be described as Direct Impregnation approach. Dry fibers are impregnated inline prior to being deposited in build volume. The deposited material is directly cured in place.
Orbital Composites - https://www.orbitalcomposites.com/
The Orb 1 machine from Orbital Composites utilizes a print head capable to directly introduce dry fiber roving into a melt flow. Therefore, the technology can be described as Direct Impregnation approach.
Technological Maturity and Points of specific Attention
Available AM-CFRP processes in market show different technological maturity. In general, the development of such processes is still at the beginning and a lot of adaptions and improvements might be realized in future. Following some basic thoughts about technology readiness and points to be considered are shared.
• Availability of pre-impregnated fiber products
The availability and variety of pre-impregnated continuous fiber-reinforced semi-finished products, especially filaments, and their prices yet constitute a barrier to a wider industrial application. Also, the quality differs. Established material suppliers just started to enter the market.
• Unrestricted real 3D-capability
If a complex geometry with three-dimensional intersecting load paths has to be created, the available technological approaches reach their limits. The stiffening of highly curved, three-dimensional shells might be possible, but free hanging curved connections between separated points in free 3D-space without restrictions cannot be realized yet. Often at least kind of a substrate, like a build plate or a previously printed structure, is needed to support the material deposition.
• Design and Fiber Path Planning
If not used to composites, the design with anisotropic materials can be challenging. A new understanding for the structural layout has to be established. Industrial software solutions supporting in unrestricted three-dimensional part optimization with anisotropic materials are in development but not yet available. Especially when it comes to the fiber path planning, which needs to be done for every single strand to be deposited, there is a lack of software products for closed digital process chains. The part design (CAD) and manufacturing planning (CAM) may be one of the current biggest challenges for wide spread applicability of AM-CFRP.
• Composite Material Microstructure and Consolidation
Processes with included consolidation step currently show high microstructural material quality particularly regarding contained void content. In other process schemes special attention should be paid to this topictopic.
• Post Processing and Assembly
To obtain high quality outer surfaces or meet tight geometrical tolerances, the manufactured parts may need to be post-processed. Also, further bonding, fastening and general assembly of composite parts need specific measures.
• Design Restrictions
Typical design restrictions for AM-CFRP parts are a minimum radius of curvature to prevent fiber misalignment, a minimum fiber path length and the handling of crossing points for fiber paths. Additionally, it needs to be understood, the cross-sectional area of the deposited strands defines the possible geometrical resolution of the part structure.
• Process Integration
AM-CFRP processes show great potential to be combined with other manufacturing processes like winding, tape laying or even metal processing. This allows to better exploit the advantages of Additive Manufacturing and allows the use of well-established manufacturing methods, where additive processes not showing strong benefits. EmpowerAX provides information how process integration can be achieved and where special attention needs to be paid for.
• Quality Assurance
Considering the final part structure can consist of thousands deposited strands successively added over a large time span, the in-line quality assurance is of high importance. The process needs to be stable and reliable as one strong imperfection in a primary load path might lead to a sudden component failure, if not recognized in advance.
• Standardization and Qualification
The final part material properties are highly affected by the specific process characteristics. For AM-CFRP processes there is a lack of agreed standards and qualification procedures for spread industrial application. These are addressed in current efforts, e.g. by EmpowerAX.
DLR Innovation Lab EmpowerAX
Working together towards fibre-reinforced 3D printing
The implementation of new technologies presents a number of challenges for companies – from selecting a suitable technology to implementing it within their existing process set-up. As a result, companies look to find all the relevant information for technology implementation combined in one place. This is precisely what the DLR Innovation Lab Empower Additive Extrusion (EmpowerAX) offers in the field of additive extrusion with continuous fibre-reinforced materials. In collaboration with suppliers and users, EmpowerAX serves as an international technology driver, developing the necessary technological expertise for the successful industrial application of additive extrusion.
EmpowerAX – a new approach to collaboration between research and industry
EmpowerAX is an international, industry-neutral technology platform. It works with technology users and providers to develop and prepare the necessary technological expertise throughout the entire process chain for additive extrusion with continuous fibre-reinforced materials and makes it available to EmpowerAX members from a single source. This enables potential end users to better assess the overall parameters of their investment and the implementation outlay required by the technology, while lowering barriers to investment and accelerating technology transfer to industry. In doing so, it drives the accessibility of additive extrusion technologies for industry.
Overview of DLR Innovation Lab EmpowerAX. Source: DLR
The starting point – Additive Extrusion as a key technology
Additive extrusion with continuous fibre reinforcement can be described as an extension of conventional 3D printing. It is considered to be a key technology for the future success of thermoplastic composites in a wide range of industrial sectors. Combining the excellent mechanical properties of continuous fibres with the design freedom offered by additive manufacturing allows the reinforcement fibres to be oriented precisely along critical load paths. This means that resilient, customised lightweight structures can be manufactured from continuous fibre-reinforced thermoplastics. However, additive extrusion with continuous fibre reinforcement is not yet established to the same extent as conventional 3D printing. This is where EmpowerAX comes in, as an international driver in the field of additive extrusion technology.
Process chain of an additive extrusion process from user´s point of view. Source: DLR
Lowering the barriers to industry application from a user perspective
- Is additive extrusion technology suitable for me as a user and in my specific industrial application environment?
- How do I choose the right technology?
- And what would I have to do to implement this technology in my application environment?
These are all questions that potential technology users are asking themselves. As an international driver of additive extrusion technology, EmpowerAX can help answer them. The EmpowerAX team, consisting of an interdisciplinary group of researchers, determines the work required based on the needs of the industry and proceeds on that basis in conjunction with the EmpowerAX members. The findings that arise from this collaborative effort are made available to industry on a shared knowledge basis, with the results finalised over several iteration loops. A cooperation agreement provides the legal framework for this collaboration.
The DLR EmpowerAX Innovation Lab offers a platform for the testing and further development of new technologies. It allows researchers to collaborate and explore the potential of the technology in an objective way, jointly develop potential application scenarios and transfer continuous fibre reinforcement to successful industrial applications.
Overview of activities of the DLR Innovation Lab EmpowerAX to users and providers of additive extrusion technologies.
Source: DLR
Why EmpowerAX?
"EmpowerAX is an international and industry-diversified technology platform encompassing the technology competence along the entire process chain in collaboration with technology users and providers. The EmpowerAX team prepares work topics demanded by industry, which are then further elaborated with industrial partners and made available in a knowledge base. The goal is to accelerate the implementation of 3D printing technologies with (continuous) fiber-reinforced materials across a broader set of industries."
(Source: Composites World, 2021)
EmpowerAX offers you as a technology user the following opportunities:
- Access to Additive Extrusion technology even if there is no prior knowledge
- Identification and pre-evaluation of application scenarios (the so-called EmpowerAX Use Case Challenges)
- Opportunity to get in contact with industrial companies, research institutions and other technology users and suppliers
- Opportunity of joint (further-) development of applications for Additive Extrusion
- Benefit from the infrastructure and technical equipment of EmpowerAX
- Assistance in implementation of Additive Extrusion technology
For you as a technology provider in the area of Additive Extrusion, EmpowerAX offers the following opportunities:
- Extended understanding of industrial needs and possible applications for your technology
- Neutral technology assessment
- Joint creation of standardization and qualification measures in the field of Additive Extrusion
- Opportunity to get in contact with industrial companies, research institutions and other technology users and suppliers
- Opportunity of joint (further-) development of applications for Additive Extrusion
- Benefit from the infrastructure and technical equipment of EmpowerAX
How to become a part of EmpowerAX?
We invite you to join the EmpowerAX platform and support the goal of using Additive Extrusion technologies in your industrial sectors in a demand-driven and targeted way.
If you are interested, please contact us.
News & recent posts of
DLR Innovation Lab EmpowerAX
4/25 - 4/27/2023: EmpowerAX @ JEC World in Paris, Hall 6, Booth S28:
Presentation of EmpowerAX Demo Part on the topic
"Additive Functionalization of a multi curved shell- Demonstration of an industrial process chain for local reinforcement"
From 25 to 27 April, we will be at JEC World 2023 in Paris, France, together with our colleagues from the DLR Institut für Bauweisen und Strukturtechnologie. At the joint Composites United stand, the institutes will present their research, technologies and services. Experts from both institutes will be available at their booth to answer questions and provide information about their activities and research.
3/23/2023: Blog article on Composites World:
Demonstrating functionalized, cost-effective composites using additive extrusion
Hybrid thermoset/thermoplastic composite part with 3D-printed functionalization demonstrates technology possibilities and EmpowerAX open platform offering expertise from members throughout the process chain.
3/16/2023: Blog article on DLR Leichtbau Blog:
From space travel to the human leg – use cases for fibre-reinforced 3D printing
Additive Extrusion technology with fibre.reinforced materials finds its ideal place of application where components with a high load-bearing capacity and a high need for customisation require a lower weight at the same time. With fibre-reinforced 3D printing, these three requirements can be combined in one component. The team behind EmpowerAX works out the suitable application scenarios with a mixture of curiosity, openness and structured methods in their various Use Case Challenges.
3/23/2023 Blog article on DLR Leichtbau Blog:
High-precision CNC robots for additive manufacturing of fibre-composite structures
Increasing sustainability and productivity is one of the biggest challenges of our time. Therefore, in industry, there is a great need for high-precision and flexible systems for additive manufacturing. At our Institute, specially designed CNC robot kinematics with a high absolute positioning accuracy allow precisely controlled path movements in three-dimensional space. In combination with specifically developed tools for the deposition of short or continuous fibre-reinforced materials, this creates an agile and flexible process for the additive manufacturing of thermoplastic fibre-composite structures.
2/3/2022: Blog article on DLR Leichtbau Blog:
DLR EmpowerAX innovation lab – working together towards fibre-reinforced 3D printing
The implementation of new technologies presents a number of challenges for companies. As a result, companies look to find all the relevant information for technology implementation combined in one place. This is precisely what the DLR Innovation Lab EmpowerAX offers in the field of additive extrusion with continuous fibre-reinforced materials. In collaboration with suppliers and users, EmpowerAX serves as the necessary technological expertise for the successful industrial application of additive extrusion.
1/20/2022: Blog article on DLR Leichtbau Blog:
Non-cutting metal replacement – continuous fibre-reinforced 3D printing filaments
A newly developed impregnation technology enables cost-effective and flexible production of continuous fibre-reinforced thermoplastic 3D printing filaments. When combined with additive material extrusion processes, this makes it possible to implement lightweight yet highly resilient components made of thermoplastic fibre composites cost-effectively, even for new businesses and manufacturers of small production runs.
7/22/2021: Blog article on Composites World:
Reducing the cost of continuous fiber 3D printing materials
DLR has developed a novel approach to produce thermoplastic impregnated fibers for lower cost versus current slit-tape materials.
7/7/2021: Blog article on Composites World:
EmpowerAX strengthens accessibility to continuous fiber 3D printing
Platform joins technology users and providers to work on standards, tests and frameworks for faster, lower-cost evaluation and implementation of additive extrusion technologies for industrial parts.
2/25/2021: Blog article on Composites World:
DLR launches EmpowerAX to industrialize continuous fiber 3D printing
Global, industry-diversified platform will increase access to additive extrusion (AX) technologies and accelerate technology transfer for users and providers.
12/4/2020: Blog article on DLR Leichtbau Blog:
3D-printed CFRP components – new impregnation technology reduces costs
A newly developed impregnation technology is set to reduce manufacturing costs for continuous fibre-reinforced thermoplastic 3D printing filaments by up to 80 percent. Impregnation capabilities integrated into the extruder nozzle open up cost-effective economic application options for industry, especially in connection with additive manufacturing processes.